It’s a wind-whipped afternoon in within the Nebraska Sandhills, and David McLay Kidd has a difficult strategy, lifeless right into a gale to a rock-hard goal that leaves little room for error. On the programs he creates, McLay Kidd likes giving golfers choices, however on this state of affairs there is just one angle of assault. Perched within the cockpit of his Piper M600, descending from an altitude of 30,000 toes, the celebrated architect locks in his line. Visibility is evident, with fierce gusts out of the south. An airstrip stretches into view and McLay Kidd banks the Piper towards it. The small airplane shakes, preventing the fan.
“If these had been crosswinds, I wouldn’t even be trying this,” McLay Kidd says. “No one wants an adventurous pilot. You need a boring pilot who follows all the principles.”
Aviation, although, is not like structure. And within the subject that made him well-known, uninteresting conformity has by no means been McLay Kidd’s factor. His aversion to enjoying it protected has been obvious for the reason that Nineties, when he rocketed to renown for his work at Bandon Dunes, on the Oregon coast. If the course was an outlier — a rugged, distant hyperlinks in an age of lushly saved, centrally situated layouts — so was its designer, a twentysomething Scotsman plucked from obscurity for the job.
Within the 25 years because it opened, Bandon Dunes has been a Prime 100 fixture and probably the most performed course on the resort that has grown round it. But the most effective measure of its import won’t be its reputation or its place within the rankings. Within the eyes of many consultants, McLay Kidd’s work represents an important pivot level in golf improvement, a before-and-after line within the business sand.
“Today, we take vacation spot golf without any consideration,” says Ran Morrissett, structure editor for GOLF. “However it’s honest to say that if the primary course at Bandon Dunes had not been so successful, there would possibly by no means have been a Sand Valley or a Streamsong or a Barnbougle Dunes.”
McLay Kidd’s profession won’t have taken off, both. As a substitute, it shot into the stratosphere, propelled by headline commissions in Hawaii, England, South Africa and past.
As with most high-flying rides, there have been bumps. Within the buzzy wake of Bandon, turbulence in his private {and professional} life prompted McLay Kidd to reassess his strategy to each. He stop consuming. And after pushing the envelope on a pair of distinguished designs that critics deemed too penal for the common participant, he got here to the soul-searching conclusion that his greatest path ahead was via his current previous.
“I did a whole lot of laborious considering,” he says. “And what I spotted was that I wanted to get again to what had guided me at Bandon and the qualities that made that course so universally liked.”
Browse GOLF’s newest Prime 100 Programs within the U.S. rating right here. And to take heed to our scores consultants break down the checklist, try our all-new journey podcast Vacation spot GOLF. Pay attention and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts: APPLE | SPOTIFY | IHEART | AMAZON
Urgent refresh helped return McLay Kidd to the highest of his sport and saved him high of thoughts for anybody seeking to construct a marquee course, a place he retains as we speak. When calls exit for plum assignments, he’s among the many first who hears a hoop.
His calendar is jammed. As of the most recent rely, DMK Golf Design, his agency based mostly in Bend, Ore., has 14 initiatives in numerous phases of improvement, from Florida to Cabo to the Coachella Valley. These embody the sixth 18-hole course at Bandon Dunes, which McLay Kidd has routed roughly half-hour down the coast from the primary resort, and a soon-to-open sibling format to his Prime 100 course at Gamble Sands, in jap Washington State.
Such commitments name for relentless journey, and although McLay Kidd isn’t alone amongst his friends in logging round-the-world air miles, he’s the one A-list architect who pilots his personal airplane. The pleasure is visceral.
“The liberty to leap throughout a mountain at excessive pace by yourself schedule — who wouldn’t need that?” he says.
However above all, the selection of transport is pragmatic. Nonetheless burningly bold at 56, McLay Kidd has additionally discovered the advantages of steadiness, and having a jet at his disposal is the quickest and easiest method out and in of Bend, the place he lives along with his spouse, Tara, and their two younger children.
On this afternoon, it’s taken barely 4 hours to make it from his doorstep to landing in central-west Nebraska, the place he’s come to mark the opening of his latest course, GrayBull, a richly entertaining design constructed on heaving, sandy land. Taxiing to a cease, McLay Kidd kills the engine, pops the hatch and slides behind the wheel of a ready automobile.
“Touring like this lets me spend extra time at residence and extra time on-site,” he says. “It’s additionally much more enjoyable in between.”
Evan Schiller
Nearly anyplace he goes as of late, McLay Kidd is a great distance from the place he began. His childhood wasn’t Dickens, but it surely additionally wasn’t Downton Abbey. The elder of two children born to working-class highschool sweethearts, he spent his youngest years on the rough-edged west aspect of Glasgow, the place his father, Jimmy, labored because the underpaid greenskeeper at an area membership. The household residence was a centuries-old stone cottage that his mother and father heated by coal-fired fireside.
As he remembers it, McLay Kidd didn’t consider his household as poor, and, even when he had, he says, it wouldn’t have mattered. His was a contented, outdoorsy upbringing. When he wasn’t at school, he shadowed his dad, pitching in on the right track upkeep, simply as he helped on the weekends when Jimmy labored a aspect gig tending to neighborhood gardens and lawns.
“Years later, I keep in mind my dad telling me that he knew that there have been actually solely three issues he might give me: confidence, self-respect and a piece ethic,” McLay Kidd says. “He was virtually apologetic to the purpose the place it upset me. I instructed him, ‘There’s nothing to be sorry about. You gave me all the things I might have ever wanted.’”
There was extra to return. By the point McLay Kidd reached highschool, Jimmy had risen to a prestigious put up as head greenskeeper at Gleneagles. To the extent that he’d plotted his personal future, McLay Kidd had at all times figured that he’d discover it in golf, almost definitely by following in his father’s footsteps. However whereas majoring in “land sciences” at England’s Writtle School, his considering shifted after his dad linked him with a summer season internship on a close-by golf course challenge being constructed by a widely known former participant.
“Besides that former participant wasn’t doing the work that basically mattered,” McLay Kidd says. “All of the necessary selections had been being made within the subject. I spotted that’s the place the motion was. And that’s the place I needed to be.”
After commencement, he apprenticed for the British architect Howard Swan earlier than one other alternative offered itself. Gleneagles had been acquired by the beverage behemoth Diageo, whose honchos had been on the lookout for a go-getter to assist them develop their golf and hospitality holdings. Right here once more, paternal connections didn’t damage. Together with his dad as a conduit, McLay Kidd assumed a job with Gleneagles Golf Growth, touring the globe searching for promising websites.
“And in order that’s how I spent the higher a part of my twenties,” he says. “Serving to Gleneagles with their grand plan to overcome the world via golf.”
It didn’t occur. What occurred as an alternative? A golf-mad Chicago businessman named Mike Keiser hatched a loopy scheme to construct a hyperlinks course on the Oregon coast.
I used to be getting large commissions, [and] I began considering, That is the place they’re going to understand I don’t know s–t.
To say the remainder is historical past leaves out quite a bit. McLay Kidd was barely 30 when Bandon opened — an in a single day star who, for all his outward self-assurance, nervous that he would possibly develop into a one-hit surprise. Presents poured in from heavy hitters. Briefly order, McLay Kidd signed on to construct a course for the bigwig businessman Fred Inexperienced, in England, and one other for Charles Schwab in Hawaii. Whereas these and different initiatives obtained raves — Nanea, on the Massive Island, debuted at No. 76 on GOLF’s checklist of the Prime 100 Programs within the World and holds a spot as we speak at No. 83 on our Prime 100 Programs within the U.S. — McLay Kidd suffered from impostor syndrome.
“I used to be getting large commissions, however the websites weren’t nearly as good [as Bandon], and the expectations had been increased,” he says. “I began considering, That is the place they’re going to understand I don’t know s–t.”
Feeling strain to outdo himself, the architect moved towards extra audacious terrain. Two strikingly daring statements had been Tetherow (2006), in Bend, and the Citadel Course (2008), in St. Andrews, a vibrant highlight of a challenge for the St. Andrews Hyperlinks Belief, simply up the street from the Outdated Course. Each designs proved polarizing — praised by many for his or her creativity but additionally seized upon by critics who discovered them over-cooked. Of the displeased voices, none captured extra consideration than that of McLay Kidd’s up to date, Tom Doak, who, in an up to date model of his course-review compendium, The Confidential Information to Golf Programs, gave the Citadel Course a zero on a scale of zero to 10 — a grade reserved for layouts “so contrived [they] most likely shouldn’t have been constructed in any respect.”
McLay Kidd contended on the time — and stays satisfied as we speak — that the zero was borne partly out of a private grievance relationship again to the early days of Bandon Dunes, the place each architects had been within the operating to construct the resort’s inaugural course earlier than Keiser went with McLay Kidd.
“Whether or not Tom can be keen to acknowledge it or not, I believe he at all times felt that I had been dropped on the mountain-top whereas he needed to work laborious to get to the summit,” McLay Kidd says. “And that bothered him.”
Doak, for his half, has repeatedly maintained that he was passing judgment solely on the Citadel Course’s design deserves. Regardless of the case, McLay Kidd says the 2 have put aside any variations, and if the zero ever stung, he now treats it with a shrug. It helps that he’s extra at peace than ever in his life.
“I’ve realized,” he says, “that I don’t must go about my days with clenched fists.”
IAN ALLEN
That’s not tough to do at a spot like GrayBull, an unbuttoned however unique redoubt — barefoot golf for the high-finance set — the place McLay Kidd will spend the following day and a half eating on wagyu beef and whacking the ball round. Regardless of its heartland surrounds, the course abides by the links-golf rules on which McLay Kidd lower his tooth. Its rollicking fairways are broad sufficient that it’s laborious to lose a ball. The more durable half is discovering the appropriate angles. Lifeless-aim aerial assaults aren’t usually the sensible selection, and leaning on energy alone can result in bother. Higher to ponder the numerous ground-game choices to targets greatest attacked by the use of pleasant contours and bouncy corridors.
It’s good, clear enjoyable, and McLay Kidd is having loads of it. However given the rhythms of his work, it’s not often lengthy earlier than there’s someplace he must be. Two mornings later, simply after dawn, he’s again within the cockpit, winging west above the clouds, his Piper set on autopilot. Although it might by no means be mistaken for a luxurious jetliner, the turboprop is loads of airplane. Not for nothing is the value tag for a brand new one $4.3 million.
Typically, when he’s breezing from right here to there — over the previous 12 months, he has taken the Piper on 84 journeys, totaling 70,000 miles — McLay Kidd marvels on the variations between then and now; how, as an illustration, the full building prices of Bandon Dunes had been decrease than the value of the airplane he flies as we speak. There’s extra money than ever within the sport’s higher reaches, and enterprise is nice for high architects, with negotiations for design charges routinely beginning within the seven figures. It’s greater than a pleasant residing. But these fats sums aren’t what totally butter McLay Kidd’s bread. Since 2001, he has additionally run his personal building firm, which serves as common contractor for most of the programs he builds.
“That’s what pays for the jet,” he says.
Because it occurs, McLay Kidd must test in on a type of initiatives. Opening his laptop computer, he boots up a video name along with his workforce at Loraloma, a personal course-in-the-making outdoors Austin, Texas, and talks via the nitty-gritty of the property’s short-game complicated. One other video convention follows with the pinnacle agronomist at Bandon Dunes for an replace on the resort’s sixth 18-holer, tentatively named New River Dunes. Each conversations are a research in effectivity, performed from his cockpit 5 miles someplace above Montana. By the point McLay Kidd closes his pc, the Rocky Mountains are behind him and the Cascades are approaching. A surprising inexperienced valley stretches beneath him. Subsequent cease: Brewster, Wash.
Like Bandon Dunes, Gamble Sands — No. 100 on this 12 months’s Prime 100 U.S. checklist — marks a watershed in McLay Kidd’s profession. Accomplished in 2014, it was his first design after a interval of introspection that returned his focus to confirmed fundamentals: The emphasis was as soon as extra on playability and enjoyable. Set amid 1000’s of acres of apple and cherry orchards, overlooking the confluence of the Columbia and Okanogan rivers, the unique course is as inviting as it’s partaking, with acres of nice fescue awaiting off the tee however loads of motion within the fairways to make sure that placement issues. The greens are massive and mellow. Suppose straightforward par, laborious birdie for a superb participant and, coupled with views, an exhilarating spherical no matter your sport.
Brian Oar
If the gorgeous simplicity of Gamble Sands was a sort of course correction for McLay Kidd, it was additionally a reminder of his items. Course raters had been impressed. So was Mike Keiser, who, after touring Gamble Sands, added McLay Kidd to a brief checklist of contenders for a challenge at Sand Valley Resort in central Wisconsin, the place McLay Kidd gained the bid for what would develop into Mammoth Dunes.
In contrast to Keiser, who has combined and matched architects in his resort expansions, the fruit-farming household behind Gamble Sands has gone all in on McLay Kidd. They introduced him again to construct QuickSands, a 14-hole par-3 design that was accomplished in 2021. They usually’ve since given him a 3rd fee: one other 18-holer, set on sandy bluffs adjoining to the unique. It should open to the general public in 2025, however on this sun-kissed afternoon, it’s grassed in sufficient to play, and McLay Kidd is keen to offer it a take a look at run.
He’s joined on the primary tee by Tory Wulf, an amiable, jeans-clad orchardist who doubles as challenge supervisor, and off they go, pounding drives on a pleasant handshake of a gap par 4. The brand new course is a sibling to the Sands however not an an identical twin. Although its fairways, too, are broad, its terrain is extra rambunctious, bucking and rolling alongside ridges and rises, and constructing in drama because it goes.
“You must name it Twisted Sister,” McLay Kidd says, as he and Wulf stroll towards their photographs. He’s joking. Sorta. “It’s actually going to be the wilder of the 2.”
Wulf offers a noncommittal snicker. (Weeks later, Gamble Sands would announce the identify of the brand new course: Scarecrow.) He and McLay Kidd have identified one another for greater than a decade, and their conversations mix biz speak and banter.
“From the day we met, I’ve identified David to be a straight shooter,” Wulf says. “I additionally know that I can rely on him being all in on what he’s doing for us. He’s as as we’re in promoting what we’ve.”
Name it what you’ll. An artwork. A craft. A golf course can be a product. McLay Kidd treats his work as the entire above. One of many sport’s nice conversationalists, he additionally ranks amongst its most interesting pitchmen, whether or not talking with the media or a enterprise mogul. Finally, although, how individuals view his efforts is out of his management. That’s one thing McLay Kidd has discovered to just accept, particularly in terms of the rankings, although such crucial assessments are much less necessary to him than widespread opinion.
“What’s fairly clear is that the rankings should not at all times a mirrored image of the programs that golfers love probably the most,” he says. “And should you requested me, would I moderately have a high-ranked course or a course that individuals take pleasure in and wish to play time and again — I’d take the latter each time.”
The afternoon is sporting on, and he and Wulf have reached the again 9 and a brief par 3. It performs to a inexperienced set on a bluff, framed by a valley panoramic, with the solar dipping low over a ridge within the backdrop. McLay Kidd pauses to drink within the vista. Within the coming weeks, he must fly to Texas after which again to Gamble Sands after which to who is aware of the place his work would possibly name him. However his subsequent flight might be within the course he’s staring. He’ll take off tomorrow, spend an hour within the air and be residence in time to place the children to mattress.
