Sunday, October 6, 2024

Why do Mercedes suspect Russell’s race-winning technique led to his disqualification? · RaceFans

George Russell received reward for his position in an audacious technique which put him in entrance on the Belgian Grand Prix.

It additionally received him the race – for round two-and-a-half hours, till he was disqualified. A post-race investigation found his Mercedes was one-and-a-half kilograms underneath the minimal weight restrict. That’s an infringement of the technical rules and the penalty was by no means prone to be something lower than disqualification.

After the race Mercedes admitted that they had suspicions that Russell’s technique had contributed to his disqualification. Whereas their closest rivals all made two pit stops, Russell gambled on making it to the top with only one.

“It’s actually robust for George to have been disqualified from the win after such a powerful drive,” mentioned Mercedes’ trackside engineering director Andrew Shovlin. “He did a superb job to hold onto the tyres and defend to the end.

“We don’t but perceive why the automotive was underweight following the race however will examine completely to seek out the reason. We count on that the lack of rubber from the one cease was a contributing issue, and we’ll work to grasp the way it occurred.”

Tyres shed rubber as they put on, forming the off-line ‘marbles’ which drivers are at pains to keep away from. The lack of rubber means they grow to be lighter, which is an element the groups need to take into consideration as a way to guarantee they keep above the minimal weight restrict.

None of that is new to groups, so Mercedes’ suspicions concerning the position Russell’s technique performed in his disqualification could appear shocking. In spite of everything, Russell used a one-stop technique within the Belgian Grand Prix final yr, so certainly Mercedes ought to have been alert to the potential implications of doing so once more?

Advert | Turn out to be a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

This isn’t the primary disqualification for a Mercedes automotive in current historical past. Final yr Lewis Hamilton misplaced his second place end in america Grand Prix when his automotive’s plank failed a post-race thickness verify.

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes, Circuit of the Americas, 2023
Mercedes have had two disqualifications previously yr

On that event the crew blamed a mistake in its set-up decisions because of the lack of apply time accessible on a dash race weekend on the bumpy Circuit of the Americas circuit the place the experience top setting is especially crucial. A scarcity of related knowledge could have been a contributing issue this weekend.

Mercedes ran a brand new ground specification on their vehicles throughout Friday apply. They weren’t pleased with its efficiency, so reverted to a earlier model from Saturday. There was no dry operating on the second day, nonetheless. No crew had a whole image of how their automotive would carry out, however Mercedes’ was probably much less clear.

A complication all groups needed to get their heads round was the monitor floor at Spa, half of which had been re-laid because the earlier yr. Degradation gave the impression to be excessive on Friday, then a stable day of rain on Saturday eliminated all of the rubber which had collected.

Groups subsequently anticipated a harsh floor on Sunday would which topic the tyres to excessive pressure. A two-stop technique regarded like the way in which to go and Mercedes thought any deviation from that will contain extra stops, not fewer.

However because the race unfolded and the floor rubbered-in, groups found the tyres have been lasting longer than anticipated. Russell hesitantly started to contemplate a one-stop technique although it went towards what they’d mentioned beforehand.

Advert | Turn out to be a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

“It was fairly backwards and forwards over the course of three laps,” he mentioned. “It’s tough as a result of whenever you really feel one thing in your intestine, you must go together with it. However when each single driver and crew is pitting to go on to a unique different technique, and in any case the information we had on Friday urged a one-stop was not even near being viable, you do type of query that a few occasions, considering, ‘are we lacking one thing right here?’ Like, why isn’t anyone else doing this?”

Max Verstappen, Red Bull, Spa-Francorchamps, 2024
Solely one of many high 4 groups examined the onerous tyres in apply

Russell could have been emboldened in his determination as he was amongst a minority of drivers who used a one-stop technique throughout final yr’s race. However the circumstances have been totally different then, although the build-up to the race noticed much more moist operating than this yr. The monitor floor was a lot much less of an unknown amount and degradation was a lot decrease groups have been content material to run the softer compounds. Russell ended his race with a 21-lap stint on C4s (softs) final yr in comparison with 34 laps on C2s (hards) this yr.

Mercedes didn’t run the onerous tyres throughout apply, which means they lacked essential data on the way it carried out. McLaren and Ferrari didn’t run it both. Among the many front-running groups just one did: Pink Bull.

After Russell’s disqualification, Pink Bull crew principal Christian Horner was in little question the rubber Russell misplaced on his one-stop technique might have introduced that automotive’s weight down sufficiently for him to fall foul of the minimal weight restrict.

“Completely, I’m certain that you’d have misplaced effectively over a kilo of rubber,” he instructed Sky. “We noticed that on Friday.”

Just one different driver one-stopped as we speak. That was Fernando Alonso, who additionally ran the onerous tyres in his ultimate stint, although switched to them three laps later than Russell. He had run the onerous tyres in apply, nonetheless, so Aston Martin would have recognized extra about its put on charge.

Advert | Turn out to be a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

So Russell was the one driver making an attempt a one-stop technique with such restricted data concerning the tyre’s efficiency. Had Mercedes realised what hassle he was in, they could have warned him to average his tempo, however he appeared to obtain no such message.

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes, Spa-Francorchamps, 2024
Hamilton inherited Russell’s win

Mercedes have been arguably unfortunate to seek out themselves on this scenario at Spa, the one monitor on the calendar the place drivers don’t carry out a victory lap after taking the chequered flag. They’re directed into the pit lane exit as an alternative. Consequently, they’ve virtually no alternative to drive on the tyre marbles, selecting up discarded rubber which helps them meet the minimal weight restrict. Nonetheless all groups need to take this into consideration at Spa.

The FIA’s clarification for Russell’s disqualification revealed the fascinating element that his automotive was on the minimal weight restrict of 798 kilograms earlier than its gasoline was eliminated. However the rules state it should move the minimal weight verify “with out gasoline”, and as soon as Russell’s W15 was drained its weight fell to 796.5kg.

“It’s a must to carry sufficient gasoline to have the ability to do the pattern, in any other case you’re utilizing gasoline as ballast,” mentioned Horner. “So, actually, unhappy information for George however clearly a mistake of their calculations.”

“We received’t be making any excuses,” mentioned Shovlin. “It’s clearly not adequate and we want to ensure it doesn’t occur once more.”

Coming inside 12 months of Hamilton’s disqualification in Austin, it was a galling blow for Mercedes. At the least on this event that they had the comfort of Hamilton’s automotive, which two-stopped to second place, capable of inherit the win.

Advert | Turn out to be a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

Miss nothing from RaceFans

Get a every day e mail with all our newest tales – and nothing else. No advertising, no advertisements. Enroll right here:

2024 Belgian Grand Prix

Browse all 2024 Belgian Grand Prix articles

Related Articles

Latest Articles