The New York Giants at present sit within the driver’s seat for the highest choose within the draft with a 2-13 report and their $160 million quarterback is on the Minnesota Vikings’ observe squad.
Placing apart any allegations of “tanking” for the highest choose within the draft, the Giants are left in a precarious spot with a comparatively weak pool of quarterback prospects and loads of holes to plug on their roster.
The consensus prime two quarterback choices, Miami’s Cameron Ward and Colorado’s Shedeur Sanders, each doubtless would have been late first rounders or second rounders in final yr’s class.
Whereas each are projected as prime 5 picks resulting from quarterback demand, they lack the normal degree of scout curiosity that prime passers have seen lately. It is harking back to the 2022 NFL Draft, the place many pundits projected former Liberty QB Malik Willis within the prime ten general earlier than he fell to the third spherical.
Whereas there’s little indication that Normal Supervisor Joe Schoen might be proven the door after this season, the choice to go away him in cost or substitute him will loom massive over the quarterback determination.
If he takes Ward or Sanders and will get fired subsequent yr, it might result in years of organizational struggles, as whoever replaces Schoen might disagree on the quarterback place and provides their “would-be” franchise quarterback much less room for error.
Supposing that Schoen does keep, he’ll need to roll the cube once more on a quarterback sooner moderately than later, and there’s no assure subsequent yr that he’ll both get the primary dart throw or that any of the quarterbacks obtainable might be higher than Ward or Sanders.
If he believes in both of the 2 prime passers on this yr’s class, he’ll doubtless really feel obligated to swing or danger by no means drafting a first-round quarterback in his GM tenure.
The choice to draft a quarterback moderately than commerce again and purchase sources can be a divisive one, as analysis on draft technique means that groups each overvalue prime draft picks and that the quarterback market within the draft is uniquely totally different from each different place.
With the variety of positional holes that the Giants have, it might make a variety of sense for them to easily refill on early-round choices for the subsequent couple of years, however it might depart Schoen probably establishing his successor moderately than taking a shot at saving his job.
One other dilemma they’re going to face if the Giants do hold Schoen and he decides to swing at quarterback is who to decide on between Ward and Sanders.
It is a determination that could possibly be influenced to some extent by possession.
For the final 20 years, the Giants have had mild-mannered and “out of the highlight” quarterbacks in Eli Manning and Daniel Jones, and the choice of Sanders can be a powerful departure from that mould.
The New York market is notorious for its capability to tear at athletes and continually poke at large personalities. Sanders’ temperament might be put underneath the microscope after a few of the spectacles throughout his time at Colorado.
The most probably end result appears to be Schoen staying, the Giants taking Ward with the primary general choose, and the entrance workplace entertaining gives in hopes of touchdown one thing that is just too good to go up. However the most probably end result is not essentially probably the most promising one.
