Matt Chapman Cashes In Early… or Late

Matt Chapman is the lone member of the so-called “Boras 4” — the quartet of top-tier free brokers who remained unsigned when spring coaching started — who has performed effectively sufficient to benefit consideration within the postseason awards voting, not solely with respect to a possible fifth Gold Glove but in addition down-ballot MVP mentions. As I famous final week, from among the many group that additionally included Cody Bellinger, Jordan Montgomery, and Blake Snell, the 31-year-old third baseman was additionally the one who appeared headed in the direction of a long-term extension along with his present staff. Late Wednesday evening, ESPN’s Jeff Passan reported that Chapman and the Giants had agreed upon a six-year, $151 million extension, one which replaces the ultimate two years of his current deal, each of which had been preceded by participant choices.

The contract finally validates Chapman’s resolution to show down what was reported as a six-year, $120 million extension provide from the Blue Jays — with whom Chapman spent 2022–23 — in some unspecified time in the future final season. Whereas the Jays pursued Chapman to some extent early in his free company, the Mariners, Cubs, and Giants had been the one different groups publicly linked to him. Chapman lastly agreed to a three-year, $54 million contract on March 2. Whereas it included opt-outs after 2024 and ’25 in addition to a mutual possibility after ’26, it was the one deal from amongst these of the Boras 4 that got here in with a decrease common annual worth than projected by our FanGraphs Prime 50 Free Brokers checklist. Checklist wrangler Ben Clemens estimated a five-year, $120 million deal ($24 million AAV), whereas the median crowdsource one was for 4 years and $80 million ($20 million AAV). The place Chapman wound up with an $18 million AAV, his new pact raises that to $25.17 million, a determine that ranks fifth amongst present third basemen:

Chapman will obtain a $1 million signing bonus after which annual salaries of $25 million by 2030. His contract doesn’t include any opt-outs, nevertheless it does have a full no-trade clause.

Chapman is the uncommon Boras consumer — although hardly the one one — to comply with an extension in-season reasonably than testing free company. Jose Altuve, Elvis Andrus, Xander Bogaerts, Carlos González and Stephen Strasburg are among the many Boras shoppers who signed such extensions throughout their stroll years, all earlier than turning into first-time free brokers; Strasburg and Bogaerts finally opted out and landed even greater offers. Adrian Beltré, one other Boras consumer, went by free company 3 times earlier than agreeing to an extension masking his closing two years with the Rangers. The purpose is that opposite to what some could imagine, Boras’ technique isn’t a one-size-fits-all march in the direction of free company. If a consumer is glad the place he’s and may get his desired wage and safety, so be it.

Chapman’s California ties are a giant consider his staying put. A local of Victorville, he was drafted by the A’s out of Cal State-Fullerton within the first spherical in 2014 and spent 5 seasons (2017–21) with Oakland earlier than being traded to Toronto. In becoming a member of the Giants this spring, he reunited with supervisor Bob Melvin, who piloted the A’s throughout his whole tenure, and third base coach Matt Williams, who served in the identical capability for Oakland in 2018–19. “This seems like dwelling for me,” he mentioned. “It seems like I’ve been right here for lots longer than one season… I really feel actually comfy within the Bay Space, and I simply love being right here.”

“I believe on this case, Matt made it clear to me all alongside that he had each piece of data we may give him and he knew what he needed to do,” mentioned Boras. “For me, that’s essentially the most rewarding half. Matt actually made a selection, and he’s glad about the place he needs to play and who he needs to play for.”

Although he’s been the one member of the Boras 4 to keep away from the injured checklist up to now, Chapman didn’t get off to a flying begin with the Giants, hitting simply .222/.266/.385 (80 wRC+) in March and April. His early-season troubles could have owed to not having a full spring coaching to ramp up, however additionally they created some trigger for concern given his 2023 season-ending funk. He hit .185/.259/.315 (60 wRC+) in August and September, missed time as a result of a sprained proper center finger, and completed with the bottom full-season totals of homers (17), RBI (54), and WAR (3.0) of his profession — all of which can have contributed to cooling his market.

As The Athletic’s Andrew Baggarly detailed on Might 13, Statcast’s bat monitoring knowledge — which exhibits Chapman with the fifth-fastest common swing of any participant — arrived simply in time to supply reassurance that he wanted solely to proceed making minor tweaks as a substitute of overhauling his mechanics or dishonest on the fastball. From Baggarly:

“That offers me the arrogance to belief that I’m coping with minor changes,” Chapman mentioned on Friday. “I don’t have to return to the lab. I don’t suppose, ‘Oh God, am I getting old?’ I do know I’m nonetheless operating quick, I’m nonetheless swinging quick, I nonetheless hit the ball laborious. I really feel good bodily. All the pieces is there. It’s simply generally there’s some fine-tuning it’s a must to do. They advised me that the opposite day: ‘Your bat pace is identical it’s all the time been. You’re elite. You’re simply working by some issues to get again on prime of the baseball.’”

Chapman has hit .254/.351/.463 (129 wRC+) with 14 homers for the reason that begin of Might, and .247/.333/.446 (118 wRC+) with a team-high 22 homers total. His slash stats are proper according to his profession marks and nearer to his Statcast anticipated numbers than final yr’s had been:

In the meantime, Chapman’s protection on the scorching nook has been good-to-great based mostly on the varied metrics; his 13 DRS leads all third basemen, whereas his 5 FRV is tied for second, and his 3.1 UZR third. Per our model of WAR, he’s fifth within the NL at 4.5 — his highest mark since 2019 — whereas per that of Baseball Reference, he’s third at 6.0, behind solely Shohei Ohtani and Francisco Lindor. Both method, that’s a participant who figures to obtain no less than some mentions on MVP ballots.

For nearly as good as Chapman has been, the Giants — who moreover added Snell and Jorge Soler after camps opened, boosting their preseason Playoff Odds to 43.4%, the sixth-highest within the NL — have gone simply 69-72. As I famous earlier this week, they had been simply 29-29 on the finish of Might, and didn’t spend a day in June or July at or above .500. They dealt Soler and Alex Cobb forward of the commerce deadline however held onto Snell regardless of heavy curiosity, and an 8-2 run pushed them to a season-high three video games above .500 (61-58) as of August 10, however they promptly fizzled, shedding 14 of their subsequent 21 video games.

Snell, who has pitched to a 1.42 ERA for the reason that begin of July after posting a 9.51 ERA and touchdown on the injured checklist twice prior, is prone to decide out of his two-year, $62 million contract. As Jon Becker identified, assuming that Snell does decide out, the Giants have slightly below $136 million dedicated to subsequent yr’s luxurious tax payroll, leaving them $104 million under the primary tax threshold after exceeding it this season. In the event that they don’t re-sign Snell, they may pursue one other frontline starter comparable to Corbin Burnes or Max Fried, which might be a necessity for them to stay aggressive inside an NL West which will ship three groups to the postseason this yr. Whereas the Giants view Chapman as a cornerstone each for his or her lineup and their clubhouse, additionally they want an impression bat in addition to some extra upgrades, notably on condition that the precise facet of their infield has mixed for simply 1.1 WAR.

As for Chapman’s contract, whereas Dan Szymborski expressed his personal reservations about its again half — his ages 35 by 37 seasons — ZiPS is reasonably optimistic in regards to the deal. Chapman’s by no means going to win a batting title, however his energy, pace (he’s within the 86th percentile for dash pace and has swiped a career-high 13 luggage this yr), and athleticism contribute to a projection for 16 WAR over the lifetime of the deal:

Wanting again to the ZiPS desk Dan supplied in March, Chapman’s sturdy season has boosted his 2025 projection upwards from 3.2 WAR, and his ’26 projection upwards from 2.6 WAR. His protection at third base initiatives to be sturdy sufficient to offset his step by step declining bat to the purpose that he ought to stay an above-average participant; even within the sixth yr, he initiatives to be price 2.2 WAR per 650 PA. ZiPS estimates a $141 million contract for these six seasons, so the precise contract represents neither a big overpay for forgoing free company nor a hometown low cost.

Boras took a whole lot of warmth for the way in which final winter performed out for his top-tier free brokers; lately, Montgomery claimed that he “butchered” his free company. Within the case of Chapman, nonetheless, the method — whereas little question painful at occasions — paid off handsomely. The third baseman has performed his method into the large cash he sought, and can earn it whereas enjoying in a spot the place he’s most comfy. The Giants clearly have work to do to return to the playoffs, however having Chapman in place helps them in the direction of that objective.