Wednesday, December 25, 2024

Ben Clemens FanGraphs Chat – 8/19/24

2:00
Ben Clemens: Hey everybody, welcome to the chat, let’s get began
2:01
Visitor: how a lot of a talent do you suppose is clutch hitting
2:02
Ben Clemens: Fairly near by no means. I’m not denying you could have a clutch or unclutch at bat however let’s put it this fashion
2:02
Ben Clemens: if clutch means performing higher in massive spots…. David Ortiz has a 0.02 “clutch” int he playoffs
2:02
Ben Clemens: he hit nearly as nicely in excessive leverage conditions as in low
2:02
Ben Clemens: He had a 140 common season wRC+ and 144 playoff wRC+
2:02
Ben Clemens: And that’s, by in style opinion, essentially the most clutch hitter of the twenty first century
2:02
Ben Clemens: so everybody else is LESS clutch??
2:03
Gronch: What’s an affordable expectation for Heliot Ramos and Tyler Fitzgerald going ahead? 3 WAR starters?
2:03
Ben Clemens: I feel that may be a completely unreasonable expectation for Fitzgerald
2:04
Ben Clemens: I don’t actually purchase his defensive worth being excessive sufficient to hold that, and I feel he’s most likely nearly a median hitter, and that this might be his greatest 12 months by a mile
2:04
Ben Clemens: clearly even the Giants don’t consider it, they’re having him bunt in additional innings
2:05
Ben Clemens: Ramos, I feel I’m in as a 2-3 WAR man, his offensive efficiency appears rather a lot nearer to the underlying stuff and I’m extra prepared to shade upwards from projections b/c of his prospect pedigree
2:05
bringbackpologrounds: What could be a extra hitter-friendly ballpark: a straight wall that’s 350 on the corners (triangle formed park), or a parabolic wall that’s 300 on the corners however 400 in middle?
2:06
Ben Clemens: this can be a nice query. Off the highest of my head the 350 one could be b/c the ability alleys and middle have a ton of batted balls within the 350-400 vary, however this seems like a enjoyable query to take a look at in additional depth later
2:06
Pat Murphy: Which one among Jacob Misirowski and Craig Yoho are becoming a member of my pen for a playoff run? Or each?
2:06
Ben Clemens: Yeah I feel each truly
2:06
Lindorphin Rush: That is random however questioning what you suppose: Innings eaters are sort of like quantity scorers. Groups are transferring away from them as a result of their worth comes from bulk, their skillsets are usually context dependent and better variance, and so they’re normally extra environment friendly when requested to do much less (ex. air it out off the bench, as a max effort 5 & dive man). Does this make any sense?
2:07
Ben Clemens: Yeah completely is smart to me. The logical extension there’s that innings eaters with above common high quality mirror the blokes who bought underrated by basketball analytics when PER was all the trend
2:07
Tacoby Bellsbury: Worse NL West harm information (and why) — Ketel Marte, Tyler Glasnow, or Ha-Seong Kim?
2:08
Ben Clemens: Marte, for me. I feel that he and Glasnow each have arguments as one of the best participant of the group, not that Kim is dangerous. After which the DBacks really feel like they’ve much less behind him, whereas the Dodgers can do their regular use a ton of pitchders you haven’t heard of who look nice after which blow out their elbows
2:08
wheelhouse: anthony volpe: completely hopeless? zero redeeming qualities on the plate
2:08
Ben Clemens: Yeah I feel he ought to most likely simply retire
2:09
Ben Clemens: He has a depressing 104 wRC+ because the All Star break, that wouldn’t even play in little league
2:10
Ben Clemens: I feel Volpe is simply going to be a protection first man who finally ends up with roughly common offense in a approach that makes Yankees followers burn him in effigy
2:10
Ben Clemens: gonna be a good time for us non-Yankee followers
2:10
woahBA: After we say somebody has a .400 wOBA within the month of july, how are the run expectancy weights calculated? Is it all the time utilizing the earlier 162 video games or simply the info from that month?
2:10
Ben Clemens: information from that 12 months
2:10
Ben Clemens: all of our wOBA is completed on a per-year foundation
2:11
sonny: For those who’re going to stroll Juan Soto why not additionally stroll Aaron Choose? Bases loaded one out towards any yankee not Soto or Choose needs to be a greater expectancy than two on one out for Choose
2:11
Ben Clemens: mmmmm… I feel the problem right here is that when you take Sizemore at his phrase and take a look at this in essentially the most optimistic potential life, it’s not about run expectancy however concerning the odds of a number of runs scoring
2:11
Ben Clemens: And if that’s what you’re optimizing for, you may’t put a man on third with lower than two outs
2:12
Who’s Fabio?: Hello Ben – a bit off matter however have you ever deliberate any ski journeys for the upcoming season?
2:12
Ben Clemens: It is determined by what you imply by “deliberate”
2:13
Ben Clemens: Particular journeys, not but. However we’ve arrange a number of flight trackers and such, planning on our annual Alta/Snowbird journey, some Tahoe journeys, and doubtless a Colorado double dip the place we fly into one and drive to a different
2:13
Visitor: When WAR totals are shut sufficient that they’re kind of the identical, what do you want to make use of as a tiebreaker?
2:13
Ben Clemens: Relies upon what I’m making an attempt to decide on
2:14
Ben Clemens: however typically talking if I’m making an attempt to find out who IS higher, not who has performed higher, I focus extra on the statistics I contemplate extra steady/predictive
2:14
Visitor: I wish to defend Masataka Yoshida. He presently has an OPS of .813 which might be sixteenth within the AL if he had sufficient PA’s to qualify and has been carrying the offense since coming back from his harm.
2:15
Ben Clemens: I might LIKE Yoshida to be a helpful contributor, I actually take pleasure in his complete recreation
2:16
Ben Clemens: the issue is that Rafaela is a large minus as an infielder and large plus as an outfielder, so taking part in him at brief to squeeze in Yoshida’s bat at DH (by placing Abreu within the area) simply doesn’t make sense
2:16
Ben Clemens: I imply, I may very well be unsuitable and Abreu may very well be the weak hyperlink right here
2:17
Ben Clemens: However I don’t htink it’s Duran or Rafaela, and it’s most likely not Tyler O’Neill?
2:17
Nick: How do you eat baseball in the course of the season? A number of screens to look at a number of video games? Concentrate on a single recreation/evening? how does Ben determine what he likes and doesn’t like in any given week!
2:17
Ben Clemens: Oh it’s very arbitrary
2:17
Ben Clemens: I’m a single recreation single display screen man, however I do leap round between video games fairly a bit
2:17
Ben Clemens: If I’m watching a non-competitive recreation and tehre’s nothing clearly grabbing my consideration, I’ll typically change
2:18
Justin: Do totally different websites have totally different win likelihood charts? ESPN’s appears off to me once I’m watching their broadcasts and so they show win likelihood on display screen.
2:18
Ben Clemens: Yeah. What historic set of video games you examine to is a lot of the distinction, I feel
2:18
Visitor: would you consider Jack Suwinski is 4-for-45 in his newest AAA stint?
2:19
Ben Clemens: I might b/c he’s on my Ottoneu crew (look, I ought to lower him, I do know) and I see his strains from time to time
2:19
Ben Clemens: my gooooodness
2:19
mason morris: Corbin Carroll! All the best way again??
2:19
Ben Clemens: Let’s simply say ‘sure’
2:19
Ben Clemens: b/c I’d be splitting hairs about something between, say, 95% and 100%
2:20
Ben Clemens: It’s wild how he was simply actually dangerous for a very long time
2:20
Ben Clemens: after which bam, simply again
2:20
Ben Clemens: it’s onerous to determine what gamers are going to do!
2:21
Jeremy: Is aid pitcher efficiency extra variable year-to-year than starter efficiency simply because relievers pitch fewer innings (=smaller pattern measurement)? Or is reliever efficiency extra variable year-to-year than starter efficiency as a result of relievers are worse pitchers than starters, and/or airing it out greater than starters?
2:21
GraphsFan: Suppose the Mariners transfer one among their younger pitchers for a hitter or two this offseason? Miller and Woo gotta be at their peaks, and Logan Gilbert crew management is beginning to dwindle.
2:21
Ben Clemens: Look, by no means say by no means, however my view has persistently been that the Mariners worth their pitching so extremely that nobody is more likely to meet their asking worth
2:22
Corbin Carroll: Am I kaput? What’s my outlook for subsequent 12 months?
2:22
Ben Clemens: Okay, wonderful
2:23
Ben Clemens: splits are all the time sort of a foolish option to say if gamers are good, b/c small samples and all, however carroll is slugging .611 because the All Star break
2:23
Ben Clemens: after all, Tyler Fitzgerald is slugging .748 because the break
2:23
DeeBo: What’s your degree of confidence in Spencer Torkelson going ahead? Would like to see him be on the middle of the youth motion in Detroit
2:24
Ben Clemens: it’s not zero…. so like, 1%?
2:24
Ben Clemens: I feel it’s actually good of them to deliver him again up and see what they’ve
2:24
Ben Clemens: nevertheless it’s not even like he hit nicely within the minors
2:25
Ben Clemens: I feel that at this level, it’s important to face details right here. There’s a fairly good likelihood that Torkelson simply doesn’t have the talents to persistently hit main league pitching at a excessive degree
2:25
Hunter: ESPN has Clase on the high of their AL Cy Younger tracker. Did they do that to make me upset?
2:25
Ben Clemens: I don’t even have any feedback right here, that’s wild
2:25
Ben Clemens: truly I lied, I do have one factor to say: use our Cy Younger tracker
2:26
Ben Clemens: not solely does it monitor what’s occurred now, it makes use of our projections to indicate how the race tasks to take a look at 12 months’s finish
2:26
Ben Clemens: and uh…. Skubal/Sale by a mile
2:26
Justin: Who’s your favourite nationwide television play-by-play man? I feel mine is Boog Sciambi
2:26
Ben Clemens: Making me choose a favourite is so merciless
2:26
Ben Clemens: oh nationwide, I used to be considering my favourite of the broadcasters
2:26
Ben Clemens: yeah Boog is nice, large fan
2:27
Ben Clemens: Joe Davis is great. Actually I feel there are a ton of excellent PBP guys doing it proper now
2:27
MVP seasons: It’s loopy to me that completely legit MVP seasons like Bryant in 2016 and even Altuve are simply going to be left within the mud by about 3 folks within the AL this 12 months
2:27
Ben Clemens: yeah each Witt and Choose are simply going bananas a lot that Soto is barely within the race
2:27
Ben Clemens: and he’s hitting .300/.432/.601 lol
2:28
Bwar: What if I instructed you that Bryce Harper has 5 seasons (together with 2015) on Aaron Choose and leads him by…. .1. Not 1! .1! (They’re each about to hit 50)
2:28
Ben Clemens: I’d consider you b/c I checked out so many foolish Choose stats once I was doing the commerce worth collection
2:28
Ben Clemens: he’s simply outrageous
2:28
Dan’l: What does Winn have to do within the final month to get within the convo for ROY?
2:29
Ben Clemens: kidnap Jackson Merrill and Paul Skenes and entice them to launch movies declaring their retirement
2:29
Brian: Do you suppose the Orioles see one thing fixable in Trevor Rogers? On deadline day the deal was a head-scratcher… and since then it solely appears worse.
2:29
Ben Clemens: I feel that they undoubtedly do
2:29
Ben Clemens: he’s been omg cowl your eyes terrible as an O, no argument there
2:30
Ben Clemens: I’m circling round writing concerning the adjustments he’s made since going to Baltimore, nevertheless it’s robust when he’s simply getting so crushed
2:30
Dk: Ideas on Mendoza calling on a scorching Jeff McNeil to sac bunt with two on and no out within the ninth?
2:30
bringbackpologrounds: Out of Hamilton, Rafaela, Abreu, or Wong, what number of grow to be long-term starters for Boston?
2:30
Ben Clemens: I really feel prefer it’s round 2.5
2:31
Ben Clemens: I feel Rafaela is one of the best of the bunch by an honest bit, at the least by way of chance of ending up as an everyday
2:31
Ben Clemens: Abreu might be gonna be a platoon man until he hits the highest a part of his distribution of outcomes, however Rafaela’s protection performs each methods
2:31
Dan’l: At this level, for the sake of 2025 and past, shouldn’t the Playing cards be giving Jordan Walker each likelihood to succeed now?? I don’t get it.
2:32
Ben Clemens: I feel so, sure
2:32
Ben Clemens: They’re taking part in just like the playoffs are nonetheless nicely inside attain, however like…. it’s getting late
2:32
Slew: Guardians was the straightforward reply to “who’s going to win the AL central?”, however with them taking part in .500 ball because the starting of June and the Twins and the Royals making noise it’s a lot much less clear. Who ya bought?
2:33
Ben Clemens: Gimme the Twins, however to be trustworthy, I feel it’s shut sufficient between the three that I’m simply selecting the group with the simplest power of schedule
2:33
Bosoxforlife: This needs to be some type of file for the worst line ever for a pitcher that bought credit score for the win, (3.1/9/6/6/4/1). Cooper Criswell within the 12-10 Pink Sox win on Friday evening which undoubtedly helps the idea that wins usually are not an effective way to evaluate a pitcher’s efficiency.
2:33
Ben Clemens: That’s….. wow
2:33
Adenolith: Anyplace I can go to see which pitchers are best to run on?
2:34
Ben Clemens: Corbin Burnes by a hilarious margin
2:35
Bosoxforlife: It appears like Chris Sale goes to lose his place as one of the best pitcher to by no means win a Cy Younger. It’s nice to see that his perseverance by accidents that would have damaged him has been rewarded.
2:35
Ben Clemens: I all the time neglect that Sale has by no means received a Cy as a result of he was so dominant at his peak
2:35
Ben Clemens: he was capable of lower by the distractions and snip out the competitors this 12 months, although
2:35
Dirk Funk: Do you consider the precise unfold in crew protection is nearer to what DRS spits out (+85 to -79 in 2023) or what FRV comes up with (+44 to -47 in 2023) ??
2:36
Ben Clemens: Oh man, I truly don’t have a robust reply for you right here
2:36
Ben Clemens: FRV mirrors what I feel, however i’ve not dug into the info to get a robust view of why the 2 are coming to such totally different conclusions
2:36
George: Actually loved Baumann’s article on Jacob Younger. The place do you suppose he matches into the 2025/2026 Nats? Stick him between Crews and Wooden or 4th Outfield PR/Defensive Alternative? Someplace within the center pending FA over the winter?
2:37
Ben Clemens: I feel it is determined by how Crews develops as a defender
2:37
Ben Clemens: If he finally ends up being above common in middle, I feel it’s important to play him there
2:37
Ben Clemens: b/c that simply opens up the power to play a extra pure bat within the nook
2:38
Luis Garcia Jr: Legit 2B starter on a contending crew or only a first rate participant on a foul crew? Looks like if he had come up final 12 months as a 23 12 months previous and was placing up this season we’d be speaking extension, however because the Nats rushed him it seems like he’s been round for eternally.
2:38
Ben Clemens: I feel he’s proper on that borderline. I’ve him pegged round league common
2:39
Ben Clemens: so like, a contender COULD begin that sort of man, however they wouldn’t be tremendous pleased with it
2:39
Warmth Stroke: Exterior of a number of gamers getting dehydrated within the Sacramento son what wacky outcomes can we anticipate from a serious league crew taking part in in a PCL stadium for a full season
2:39
Ben Clemens: a swarm of children on a grassy berm chase an Aaron Choose milestone residence run ball and inadvertently push Zack Hample onto the sector
2:40
eline: what’s your prediction for the guardians yankees collection
2:40
Ben Clemens: Anthony Volpe will key a Yankees collection victory, Yankees followers will name for him to get replaced by Derek Jeter
2:40
Ben: Why isn’t each weekend participant’s weekend?  Why does MLB care what the bats and spikes of gamers seem like?
2:40
Ben Clemens: I feel b/c it’d look slightly bizarre if guys had been utilizing the pencil bat each week
2:41
Ben Clemens: however yeah, to some extent they already don’t, you understand?
2:41
Ben Clemens: you may virtually put on no matter cleats you need
2:41
IV: Very a lot take pleasure in your MLB baseball protection, however any fast OOTP league updates for us?
2:41
Ben Clemens: I’m not taking part in this 12 months
2:41
Ben Clemens: I’ll be again subsequent 12 months however I used to be simply spending an excessive amount of time on it
2:43
woahBA: Wanting on the cy younger predictor, how do you interpret cyp or fip-cyp. If skubal has 120 fip-cyp and ragans has 91, does that translate into some sort of x% likelihood skubal wins the cy. Extra factors is best, however how a lot better
2:43
Ben Clemens: right here’s a snippet from tango’s weblog on the system that does a historic back-check on it
2:43
Ben Clemens: Each single Cy Younger winner completed 1st or 2nd in Cy Younger factors, since 2006, with out exception. None. And even those that completed 2nd had been inside putting distance (4 factors) of 1st place. So the rule is easy sufficient: when you lead the league in Cy Younger factors, or are inside 4 factors of the chief, you’re the solely candidates to win the Cy Younger. That is true for the 30 awards from 2006-2020. 30 for 30.
2:43
Ben Clemens: I wouldn’t name it that good, and notably on the projecdted aspect, b/c the projections have tons of vraiance
2:43
Ben Clemens: however a 30 level lead is mainly 100%
2:44
DeeBo: Ohtani has a practical shot at being the primary ever member of the 50/50 membership…
2:44
Ben Clemens: The man is simply actually outstanding
2:44
Ben Clemens: my confidence that he’d be a perennial MVP candidate if he by no means pitched once more has skyrocketed this 12 months
2:45
Visitor: The place is hyperlink to the pre-season the place y’all ran odds for each crew in the event that they misplaced their 1,2,3,4,5 greatest gamers? Searched however couldn’t discover it. And subsequent 12 months, please go away the Braves out of the train and the voodoo has been very unkind this season…
2:45
Ben Clemens: it’s actually wild how the Braves have been hit by harm
2:45
Ben Clemens: subsequent 12 months we will certainly not single out one crew b/c jeeeeez
2:45
Braves Apologist: Riley out 6-8 weeks.  Has anybody ever misplaced the quantity of expertise in a single season to harm that the bravos have this 12 months.
2:45
Ben Clemens: Nothing involves thoughts
2:45
Ben Clemens: it’s been wild
2:46
Mr. Burrito: I really like the Dodgers. I’m carrying Dodgers underwear as we converse. However is it honest at this level to ask if the vaunted participant growth machine can be breaking pitchers? I do know numerous pitchers get damage, in each group, however we’re at some extent the place if it had been a unique crew — one with a worse monitor file at participant growth, for instance — that we’d be asking that query. Ideas?
2:47
Ben Clemens: I feel it’s a really legitimate query to ask. I don’t have reply for you, and I dn’t actually wish to speculate on such a consequential query
2:47
Didace: Garcia Jr. is fifth in WAR for 2nd base this season. You’re not shopping for it?
2:48
Ben Clemens: I’m not shopping for his 2020-2023 line both (0.4 wins BELOW alternative)
2:48
Greg: Do you suppose that he truly meant that the wall could be 350 ft away from the plate all over the place? As a result of a straight wall making a triangle formed park could be considerably shorter to CF, wouldn’t it?
2:48
Ben Clemens: yeah I’m picturing 350 all over the place
2:49
Ben Clemens: an precise triangle park, agreed, one thing about hypotenuse math
2:49
Brian: Patrick Bailey is a good defensive backstop in line with Statcast and different metrics, however he has slumping very onerous. He additionally had a hunch later final 12 months as a full time catcher. Is he a full time catcher sooner or later if he retains on slumping on the finish of the season? Is that this only a fluke and hoping he is ready to rebound after one other season within the books?
2:50
Ben Clemens: If I had been the Giants, I’d be very targeted on determining whether or not Bailey is bodily drained, mentally drained, whether or not it’s a fluke, wahtever
2:51
Ben Clemens: His bat velocity hasn’t modified, which doesn’t essentially inform us something. It’s price noting that he has a .151 BABIP because the break, so like, that most likely received’t hold taking place
2:51
Ben Clemens: however he’s alos not hitting the ball onerous, and never strolling
2:52
Bosoxforlife: I’ll point out my expertise with the ABS system final Friday at Worcester. There have been 4 challenges. 3 by hitters, 1 overturned, and 1 by a pitcher which was overturned. It was fast and environment friendly and whereas I need all pitches referred to as by ABS it was a optimistic expertise.
2:52
Ben Clemens: I nonetheless haven’t seen a recreation with ABS challenges however I’d prefer to
2:52
Jake: Who performs third for the braves tomorrow?
2:53
Ben Clemens: we now have luke williams as our guess, Zack Brief makes some sense too
2:53
Ike Melias: Is there one thing particular that’s inflicting a lot of the O’s high rookies to wrestle so badly of their preliminary publicity to the bigs, or simply basic proof that baseball is difficult? I do know we’re speaking SSS, however watching Cowser, Holliday, and now Mayo all look helpless for his or her first few weeks has been irritating.
2:53
Ben Clemens: I feel simply baseball is difficult
2:53
Ben Clemens: Adley seemed like he belonged instantly, for instance
2:54
Ben Clemens: alright, I’ve to move out a bit early at the moment, thanks for chatting with me although, and have an excellent week. I’ll be again on the similar time subsequent week

 

Ben is a author at FanGraphs. He could be discovered on Twitter @_Ben_Clemens.

Related Articles

Latest Articles