5 WNBA Defensive Participant of the Yr candidates, together with A’ja Wilson and DiJonai Carrington

Defensive Participant of the Yr is among the hardest awards to find out in skilled basketball. There’s the query of whether or not guards can ever influence a sport defensively the identical means that put up gamers can (see: DiJonai Carrington), and a dilemma concerning whether or not somebody ought to have the ability to earn the honors if their group’s protection has been underwhelming (see: A’ja Wilson).

There’s additionally a query round how a lot counting stats like blocks and steals matter versus extra superior analytics.

Although it’s not an ideal science, I picked my 5 candidates for Defensive Participant of the Yr, all of whom needs to be on the All-Protection Crew as effectively.

Napheesa Collier, Minnesota Lynx

Picture by Stephen Gosling/NBAE through Getty Photographs

Blocks: 1.4 blocks (sixth)
Steals: 1.9 steals (4th)
Defensive Ranking: 91.4 (1st)
Defensive Win Shares: 3.6 (2nd)

Napheesa Collier is ESPN’s choose for Defensive Participant of the Yr, and it’s simple to know why. The Minnesota Lynx have had the second-best protection within the league this, and Collier has one of the best defensive particular person ranking of any participant.

The frontcourt partnership between Collier and Alanna Smith has been significantly efficient.

“I’m actually fortunate in that Phee and I play rather well off of one another defensively,” Smith informed SB Nation. “That was form of one thing that occurred from the very begin with us. It was identical to, we learn one another rather well and labored collectively rather well on the defensive finish, with out having to do a lot.”

A’ja Wilson, Las Vegas Aces

Picture by Ethan Miller/Getty Photographs

Blocks: 2.6 (1st)
Steals: 1.8 (fifth)
Defensive Ranking: 92.3 (2nd)
Defensive Win Shares: 3.8 (1st)

A’ja Wilson leads the league in blocks and has probably the most steals of her profession. She has the very best Defensive Win Share of any participant within the W, and the second-highest defensive ranking. The most important knock on her candidacy is the actual fact the Aces have had the fifth greatest protection this season, beneath the opposite candidates on this listing.

Wilson has gained the award in each 2022 and 2023, so if she have been to take this one house, she’d be the first participant in WNBA historical past to win the award three consecutive years. To her, continued success and enchancment is all the time the purpose.

“It doesn’t matter what number of MVPs, it doesn’t matter what number of championships: my factor is to get higher each single yr,” Wilson informed SB Nation. “I would like somebody to say, ‘Rattling, she labored on that. Oh, rattling, she received good at that.’ That’s the largest factor. That’s why it doesn’t come as a shock to me.”

Breanna Stewart, New York Liberty

Picture by Sam Hodde/Getty Photographs

Blocks: 1.3 (sixth)
Steals: 1.7 (seventh)
Defensive Ranking: 93.6 (4th)
Defensive Win Shares: 3.4 (third)

Breanna Stewart is a perennial Defensive Participant of the Yr candidate, however she’s by no means truly gained the award. The Liberty have the league’s third-best protection this season, and Stewart has been an enormous cause why. Her versatility has stood out, and the Liberty have benefitted from having her play alongside Jonquel Jones as a rim protector.

“I believe the place I’ve improved probably the most defensively is the perimeter, the guard protection,” Stewart informed SB Nation. “I really feel like this yr, particularly, we’re switching much more, which is placing me on guards and making an attempt to be sure that I’m utilizing my size, I’m capable of block photographs, I’m capable of get steals. Actually simply the attention of — what’s the offense making an attempt to do, and the way can I disrupt it?”

Successful the honour for the primary time would imply lots to the 2x MVP.

“Simply because I do know what I can do offensively, however to essentially form of proceed to remodel into an elite two-way participant is a purpose of mine,” Stewart mentioned. “And, simply understanding that I used to be making an influence and a distinction on my group, on each ends of the ground.”

DiJonai Carrington, Connecticut Solar

Picture by Chris Marion/NBAE through Getty Photographs

Blocks: (0.4)
Steals: 1.6 steals (ninth)
Defensive Ranking: 96.2 (eighth)
Defensive Win Shares: 2.6 (ninth)

The Connecticut Solar have one of the best protection within the league, and DiJonai Carrington is their greatest defender. She’s usually tasked with guarding opposing group’s greatest gamers. Carrington has the fourth-most steals per sport amongst guards. Whereas she’s a bit decrease than the remainder of the pack in Defensive Ranking and Defensive Win Shares, Carrington is first amongst guards in these classes.

Solar head coach Stephanie White issues Carrington is a worthwhile candidate.

“We take a look at the numbers on a regular basis, and she or he is persistently holding opponents’ greatest perimeter gamers underneath their averages or holding them to poor taking pictures percentages.”

Carrington informed SB Nation she is conscious of the DPOY marketing campaign for her, however that she’s not attaching her price to it.

“I’m on social media, and I see individuals discussing it, and so they’re doing campaigns and stuff,” Carrington mentioned. “I’m used to not getting acknowledged or accolades. I’ve simply by no means been the kind of participant that wants the general public recognition, so it will clearly be a tremendous honor and funky, and all of these issues.”

Ezi Magbegor, Seattle Storm

Picture by Steph Chambers/Getty Photographs

Blocks: 2.2 (2nd)
Steals: 1.1 (twenty fifth)
Defensive Ranking: 95.9 (seventh)
Defensive Win Shares: 2.7 (eighth)

Ezi Magbegor has anchored the Seattle Storm’s protection all yr, and the Storm have been stable on that finish (96.6 defensive ranking, good for fourth total). The issue, nonetheless, is that she ranks decrease than Wilson in each class, and decrease than Collier and Stewart in all however one. So, in that sense, it’d be onerous to make a case for her over the opposite put up gamers on this race.

Nonetheless, her teammates and coaches have relentlessly campaigned for her. Gabby Williams mirrored on Magbegor’s defensive influence after a win over the Sparks final week.

“It makes issues so tough when you’ve got somebody like that who’s equally tall, equally athletic, equally good defensively, who’s hounding you on the ball… as a result of you already know you may’t do something when Ezi traps you,” Williams mentioned. “So not solely simply her presence on the rim, however her ball stress, I believe. And likewise, whenever you — if she’s not blocking photographs, you’re scared to drive as a result of you already know that you’ve a shot blocker behind. So simply her presence makes it lots simpler for us.”

Storm teammate Skylar Diggins-Smith merely repeated: “DPOY.”

Final 5 Winners:

• 2019: Natasha Howard, Seattle Storm
• 2020: Candace Parker, Los Angeles Sparks
• 2021: Sylvia Fowles, Minnesota Lynx
• 2022: A’ja Wilson, Las Vegas Aces
• 2023: A’ja Wilson, Las Vegas Aces